THE DAPPER DON'S LEDGER: John Gotti
The Story
Courts finally caught Gotti on ledger they could prove: murders of Castellano and Bilotti, racketeering, tax evasion that finally made Teflon peel. But entry for John Favara was never balanced by any court in this country. It sits open still, debt Gambino family never had to pay in daylight, settled instead in whatever dark water or acid drum holds only witness who could ever tell us for certain.
The Dapper Don's Ledger I have been asked to look into a dead man who is not officially dead and a live man who has been called by more names than the law could ever make stick. This is the kind of case that does not end with a confession, only with a silence so complete it becomes its own kind of answer. Call it an accounting of debts. Call it a ledger with one entry that was never closed. The Climb He came up out of the Bronx in 1940, one of 13 children, born John Joseph Gotti Jr., a name that would eventually wear a half dozen aliases the way other men wear overcoats.
He started as a dela croce loyalist. a street captain running a crew out of a Queen's social club, and Agnello della Croce, a high -ranking member of Carlo Gambino's crime family, eventually served as his mentor, sponsoring the young man as he climbed through organized crime. Gotti initially became a soldier in the Gambino family, serving as a hitman, among other roles, and in 1974, he pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of John McBrattney and served two years. A man learns patience in a cell. He learns who owes him when he gets out.
The trouble started with a succession that never sat right. Gotti's faction resented Paul Castellano's appointment as head of the Gambino family in 1976. To Gotti and his colleagues, Castellano represented the white collar wing of the business, the legal fronts, and the concrete contracts, a long way from the street. Della Croce kept the peace while he lived. Then he stopped living. The divide boiled over after De La Croce's death on December 2nd, 1985. Days later, Gotti and several other captains concluded that Castellano lacked legitimacy and decided to assassinate him.
and part of what decided it was an insult that cost nothing to give and everything to take back. When Castellano did not attend De La Croce's funeral in early December 1985, his display of disrespect angered Gotti and his blue -collar faction. On the night of the 16th, Gotti and his allies had Castellano gunned down outside a steakhouse in Manhattan, and Gotti reportedly watched the hit from a nearby car. Both Castellano and his underboss, Thomas Bellotti, were murdered in the restaurant ambush at Sparks Steakhouse.
In early 1986, Gotti was recognized as the boss of the Gambino family. He had broken the oldest rule in the business, killing his own boss without sanction. And the commission let it stand because, by then, there was no one left who wanted the trouble of saying otherwise. The Teflon Years A man who kills his way to the top usually knows enough to disappear into the wallpaper afterward. Gotti did the opposite. With his expensive suits, lavish parties, and illegal dealings, he quickly became something of a media celebrity, and the press dubbed him the Dapper Don.
But a tailored suit does not keep a man out of a courtroom, and between 1986 and 1990, the government tried three times to put him away. Between 1986 and 1990, Gotti was tried three times and acquitted each time. Journalists dubbed him the Teflon Don because no charges stuck. It was a good nickname. It was also a lie dressed as a compliment. It was later revealed that the trials were tainted by jury tampering, juror misconduct, and witness intimidation. One failed because the jury foreman was paid a $60 ,000 bribe.
In the 1986 racketeering case, Gotti had scored a ringer juror who had lied about his relationship with the leader of the Westies mob to get on the panel. And when deliberations began, most jurors favored conviction. But when the planted juror held out for acquittal, the rest became so frightened for their own safety that they voted to acquit on all charges. Nothing stuck because nothing was allowed to. The run ended the way these runs always end. with a man closer than a brother deciding his own skin mattered more than the oath.
With extensive court authorized electronic surveillance, diligent detective work, and the eventual cooperation of Gotti's underboss, Sammy the Bull Gravano, the Bureau and the NYPD built a strong case against him. On April 2nd, 1992, Gotti was convicted on 13 counts, including the murders of Castellano and Bellotti. Somebody at the Bureau put it better than I could. The Don is covered with Velcro and every charge stuck. He died of cancer a decade later, still in a federal cell, and by then the nickname had curdled into a punchline.
The boy on the minibike. But a case file is not a man's whole life, and the part of this one that keeps me up nights never made it into any indictment. Favaro worked as a service department manager for the Castro Convertibles furniture store, and his adopted son was a close friend of the Gotti children. which tells you something about the kind of ordinary life this was before it stopped being ordinary. On March 18, 1980, while returning home from work, Favara struck 12 -year -old Frank Gotti, who darted into the street on a motorized minibike from behind a dumpster.
The boy had just made his school's football team that day. He had no way of knowing it would be the last good news of his life. He was dragged down the entire block, pinned beneath Favara's car. Gotti was killed. but no charges were ever filed against Favara as it was ruled an accident. The law closed its file in a day. The neighborhood never did. The boy's mother, Victoria Gotti, tried to attack Favara with a baseball bat, though she missed every swing, and Favara did not file charges against her.
That restraint did him no good at all. Favara received multiple death threats, and his car was vandalized with the word murderer. Aware of Gotti's reputation, Favara decided it was best for his family to relocate. He never got the chance to leave quietly. What is believed to have happened? On July 28th, 1980, four months to the week after the accident, John Favara was last seen leaving his place of work in New Hyde Park. According to witnesses, people were seen beating Favara and tires were heard squealing away from the scene.
Witnesses reported seeing him shoved into a van by several men. He was never seen again, not by his wife. not by his two sons, not by anyone who could tell a courtroom what came next with any certainty. After the abduction, Favara's wife and two sons moved out of Howard Beach, which is what you do when a neighborhood has already delivered its verdict and you know better than to wait for an appeal. Here is where the file goes soft, the way they always do when the truth is this inconvenient. Jerry Capecci, an author and expert on the mafia who has written extensively on Gotti, said rumors circulated that Favara's body had been put into a cement -filled oil drum and dropped in the ocean.
Other accounts disagree entirely. It is perhaps the most intriguing unsolved mystery from the gangland career of John Gotti. Whatever happened to the neighbor who accidentally ran over and killed the mobster's 12 -year -old son and then vanished? According to papers filed in Brooklyn Federal Court, Favara was shot to death on orders of the outraged Gambino family chief, and his body was dissolved in a barrel of acid. and a cooperating witness identified Charles Carnegie as the killer. Two stories.
A drum in the Atlantic or a drum of acid in a junkyard. And not one ounce of either man's remains ever surfaced to settle the argument. Favara's remains have never been discovered. Gotti was, by every account, a long way from Queens when it happened. He had left on a Florida vacation three days before Favara's disappearance. A careful man builds himself an alibi before he builds a motive. When detectives came calling anyway, he did not bother pretending at grief. When questioned by two detectives on Favara's disappearance, Gotti said, I'm not sorry the guy's missing.
No one was ever charged with it. No body was ever recovered. No confession ever entered into evidence. And the case sits today exactly where it sat in the August heat of 1980. A presumption, not a verdict. He disappeared on July 28th, 1980. over four months after he struck and killed Gotti's 12 -year -old son Frank with his car. And three years later, the courts did the only thing left to do with a man who had become a rumor. He was declared legally dead. Accounts differed on what was done with his body.
Closing the file. I have handled cases with cleaner endings. This one ends on a man's own words, spoken to detectives who already knew better than to expect a different answer, and on a silence that has now outlasted the Don who profited from it. The courts finally caught Gotti on the ledger they could prove, the murders of Castellano and Bellotti, the racketeering, the tax evasion that finally made the Teflon peel. But the entry for John Favara was never balanced by any court in this country. It sits open still, a debt the Gambino family never had to pay in daylight, settled instead in whatever dark water or acid drum holds the only witness who could ever tell us for certain.
Some cases close with a judge's gavel. Others closed the way this one did, with a neighborhood that stopped asking questions because it already knew the answer it would get for asking them. As always, stay curious, my friends.
Podbean