All Episodes
S1E78
JIMMY COONAN: The Kid Who Never Forgot
•10:13

JIMMY COONAN: The Kid Who Never Forgot

0:00 / 10:13

The Story

Coonan's father never told it straight. He told it the way a man tells a thing that still hurts: flat, fast, no color in it.

They came for him on a street he'd walked for twenty years and they worked him over with pistol butts until the bone under his eye came loose from its socket, and then they let him go because that was the message, not the beating. Mickey Spillane's crew did the collecting in Hell's Kitchen those years, and John Coonan owed somebody something. His son was fourteen. He watched his father's face set wrong for the rest of his life and he didn't forget it.

James Michael Coonan. Born December 1946, Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan. Quit school at 17, fists already paying his way. Wasn't big. Didn't need to be. Had the willingness to go all the way when another man stops at three-quarters.

By 19, first move against Spillane: climbs tenement roof, empties 30-round machine gun magazine at Spillane and crew. No one dies. Announcement, not ending. Marks start of Coonan-Spillane feud.

Spillane goes and finds John Coonan, slaps him across the face in the street, tells him to control his boy. Doesn't work. Coonan state takes off board for kidnapping/killing pled down to manslaughter. Out late 1971, older, colder, same ambition: Mickey Spillane's job.

Mid-70s picks up Vietnam vet Mickey Featherstone — choirboy face, no bottom once shooting starts. Becomes right hand.

Meanwhile, Jacob K. Javits Convention Center construction. Genovese family wants piece. Spillane says no. Genovese brings in Joseph "Mad Dog" Sullivan. Sullivan kills Spillane lieutenants: Eddie "the Butcher" Cummiskey Aug 20 1976 in Sunbrite bar, Tom Devaney, Tom "the Greek" Kapatos. Spillane's organization gutted.

1977: Loan shark Ruby Stein — Gambino-connected — murdered and beheaded. Testimony 1987 by ex-Westies member turned informant William Beattie: Coonan had Stein killed and beheaded to erase debt and prove Westies power through viciousness. Killing brings Coonan into contact with Gambino soldier Roy DeMeo, Brooklyn Flatlands crew.

Deal: Eliminate Spillane, Gambinos bless successor. Roy DeMeo, Gambino soldier, murders Spillane as favor to Coonan — never proved in court, no conviction. May 13, 1977, Spillane shot down 59th St Woodside Queens. Mickey Featherstone arrested, tried, acquitted. File stays open.

Spillane death puts West Side in Coonan's hand. Tightens alliance with Westies and Gambinos under Paul Castellano. Terms: 10% of illegal proceeds to family, Gambinos finance loansharking. Castellano chastises Westies for murdering two important Mafia loan sharks. Coonan trades Spillane's boot for Castellano's.

Jan 1978: Coonan with Featherstone and Anton Lucich shoots and dismembers loansharking associate Richard Tassiello for skimming.

1979: Tried for Harold Whitehead murder, acquitted, convicted weapons charges, 4 years federal prison. Does time, comes home, resumes power. Arrested for murder again 1986.

April 1985: Westie Michael Holly murdered, Billy Bokun involvement. Frame built pointing at Featherstone. March 1986 jury convicts Featherstone, 25 years. Featherstone realizes Coonan sold Hell's Kitchen to Italians, kept proceeds. Wife Sissy Featherstone wears wire, gets Bokun talking on tape about disguise.

With Sissy evidence, conviction overturned Sept 1986, Featherstone becomes informant.

With Featherstone info 1986, prosecutors obtain indictments against eight members of Westies including leader Jimmy Coonan. Sept 17, 1987, US Attorney and Manhattan DA hand up RICO indictment against Coonan and nine others including wife Edna Coonan: extortion, loansharking, gambling, narcotics, kidnapping,

Coonan remains federal institution, Pennsylvania, still filing appeals. Boy who climbed tenement roof got everything he wanted — just never got to keep it clean.

. Fireside Chat with Cage.

Stay curious, my friends.

Key Takeaways

  • James Michael Coonan was born in Hell’s Kitchen, Manhattan, in December 1946.
  • Coonan’s feud with Mickey Spillane began after Coonan fired a machine gun at Spillane and his crew; no one was killed.
  • Coonan became leader of the Westies after Spillane was murdered in May 1977. The notes say Roy DeMeo’s role in the killing was never proved in court.
  • In 1987, a RICO indictment charged Coonan and nine others with crimes including extortion, loansharking, gambling, narcotics, and kidnapping.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who was Coonan’s right-hand man?

Mickey Featherstone.

When was Mickey Spillane killed?

May 13, 1977.

What helped Featherstone become an informant?

Evidence from his wife, Sissy Featherstone, helped overturn his conviction in September 1986; he then became an informant.