JIMMY COONAN: The Kid Who Never Forgot
The Story
Coonan's father never told it straight. He told it the way a man tells a thing that still hurts: flat, fast, no color in it.
They came for him on a street he'd walked for twenty years and they worked him over with pistol butts until the bone under his eye came loose from its socket, and then they let him go because that was the message, not the beating. Mickey Spillane's crew did the collecting in Hell's Kitchen those years, and John Coonan owed somebody something. His son was fourteen. He watched his father's face set wrong for the rest of his life and he didn't forget it.
James Michael Coonan. Born December 1946, Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan. Quit school at 17, fists already paying his way. Wasn't big. Didn't need to be. Had the willingness to go all the way when another man stops at three-quarters.
By 19, first move against Spillane: climbs tenement roof, empties 30-round machine gun magazine at Spillane and crew. No one dies. Announcement, not ending. Marks start of Coonan-Spillane feud.
Spillane goes and finds John Coonan, slaps him across the face in the street, tells him to control his boy. Doesn't work. Coonan state takes off board for kidnapping/killing pled down to manslaughter. Out late 1971, older, colder, same ambition: Mickey Spillane's job.
Mid-70s picks up Vietnam vet Mickey Featherstone — choirboy face, no bottom once shooting starts. Becomes right hand.
Meanwhile, Jacob K. Javits Convention Center construction. Genovese family wants piece. Spillane says no. Genovese brings in Joseph "Mad Dog" Sullivan. Sullivan kills Spillane lieutenants: Eddie "the Butcher" Cummiskey Aug 20 1976 in Sunbrite bar, Tom Devaney, Tom "the Greek" Kapatos. Spillane's organization gutted.
1977: Loan shark Ruby Stein — Gambino-connected — murdered and beheaded. Testimony 1987 by ex-Westies member turned informant William Beattie: Coonan had Stein killed and beheaded to erase debt and prove Westies power through viciousness. Killing brings Coonan into contact with Gambino soldier Roy DeMeo, Brooklyn Flatlands crew.
Deal: Eliminate Spillane, Gambinos bless successor. Roy DeMeo, Gambino soldier, murders Spillane as favor to Coonan — never proved in court, no conviction. May 13, 1977, Spillane shot down 59th St Woodside Queens. Mickey Featherstone arrested, tried, acquitted. File stays open.
Spillane death puts West Side in Coonan's hand. Tightens alliance with Westies and Gambinos under Paul Castellano. Terms: 10% of illegal proceeds to family, Gambinos finance loansharking. Castellano chastises Westies for murdering two important Mafia loan sharks. Coonan trades Spillane's boot for Castellano's.
Jan 1978: Coonan with Featherstone and Anton Lucich shoots and dismembers loansharking associate Richard Tassiello for skimming.
1979: Tried for Harold Whitehead murder, acquitted, convicted weapons charges, 4 years federal prison. Does time, comes home, resumes power. Arrested for murder again 1986.
April 1985: Westie Michael Holly murdered, Billy Bokun involvement. Frame built pointing at Featherstone. March 1986 jury convicts Featherstone, 25 years. Featherstone realizes Coonan sold Hell's Kitchen to Italians, kept proceeds. Wife Sissy Featherstone wears wire, gets Bokun talking on tape about disguise.
With Sissy evidence, conviction overturned Sept 1986, Featherstone becomes informant.
With Featherstone info 1986, prosecutors obtain indictments against eight members of Westies including leader Jimmy Coonan. Sept 17, 1987, US Attorney and Manhattan DA hand up RICO indictment against Coonan and nine others including wife Edna Coonan: extortion, loansharking, gambling, narcotics, kidnapping,
Coonan remains federal institution, Pennsylvania, still filing appeals. Boy who climbed tenement roof got everything he wanted — just never got to keep it clean.
. Fireside Chat with Cage.
Stay curious, my friends.
Coonan's father never told it straight. He told it the way a man tells a thing that still hurts. Flat, fast, no color in it. They came for him on a street he'd walked for 20 years, and they worked him over with pistol butts until the bone under his eye came loose from its socket. And then they let him go, because that was the message, not the beating. Mickey Spillane's crew did the collecting in Hell's Kitchen those years, and John Coonan owed somebody something. or somebody said he did, which in that neighborhood came to the same thing.
His son was 14. He watched his father's face set wrong for the rest of his life, and he didn't forget it. And in a place like Hell's Kitchen, a boy who doesn't forget grows up into a man who collects. James Michael Coonan was born in December of 1946 and quit school at 17 with his fists already paying his way. He wasn't big. He didn't need to be. He had the thing that matters more in that trade than size, which is the willingness to go all the way when another man stops at three quarters, and everybody on 10th Avenue learned it about him early.
By 19, he'd made his first move against Spillane, and it was not subtle. He climbed up on a tenement roof with a machine gun and emptied a full magazine down at Spillane and the men around him. 30 rounds. Nobody died. It wasn't meant as an ending. just an announcement, and it marked the start of a feud between Coonan and Spillane's crew. Spillane took it exactly as seriously as a man should who's just had 30 rounds fired at him by a teenager. He went and found John Coonan and slapped him across the face in the street, man to man, father to father, and told him to get his boy under control.
It didn't work. Nothing was going to work. The state took Coonan off the board for a few years after that on a kidnapping and killing that got pled down to manslaughter, and he came out in late 1971 the same man who went in, older and colder, and went straight back to the only job he'd ever wanted, which was Mickey Spillane's job. He built slowly, the way men build who intend the thing to last. He picked up loose talent on the corners. the kind of hard case that gravitates toward whoever looks most likely to win.
And in the mid -70s, he picked up a Vietnam veteran named Mickey Featherstone, a kid with a choir boy face who turned out to have no bottom to him at all once the shooting started. Featherstone became Coonan's right hand, and together they went to work peeling Spillane's organization away from him piece by piece. Spillane had other troubles that weren't Coonan's doing, but helped Coonan's cause the way a flood helps a man already building a boat. The Genovese family wanted a piece of the construction money coming out of the new convention center going up on the west side, and Spillane told them no, which, in that business, is a decision a man makes exactly once.
The Genovese people brought in a hitman named Joseph Sullivan, and Sullivan went to work on Spillane's lieutenants one at a time. Eddie Kamisky went down in a bar in August of 1976. Tom Devaney went down. Tom Kapatos went down. By the time Sullivan was finished, Spillane had an organization with its head still attached, but most of its arms and legs gone, and Coonan and Featherstone stepped into the gap like men stepping into a room somebody else had already cleared. In 1977, Coonan did a piece of business that told everybody in that end of Manhattan exactly what kind of outfit he was running now.
A loan shark named Ruby Stein, a man with mafia money behind him, turned up dead and without his head. And the story that came out years later in a federal courtroom told by a Westie named William Beatty, who turned state's witness, was that Kuhnen had Stein killed and beheaded both to wipe out a debt and to put on a show of exactly how far his people would go. Testimony given in 1987 by ex -Westies member turned informant William Beatty said Stein was killed and beheaded in 1977 in a move to erase Coonan's debt and prove the Westies' power through viciousness.
It worked. Killing a man connected to the Gambino family ought to have brought the Gambinos down on Coonan's head. Instead, it brought Roy DeMeo, a Gambino soldier with his own appetite for the kind of man who didn't flinch, and Dimeo and Coonan found they had use for each other. Spillane's death put the whole West Side in Coonan's hand, and he held it for a decade. He didn't hold it alone, though. Not the way he'd planned to. Coonan tightened the alliance between the Westies and the Gambinos, then run by Paul Castellano, and the terms of that alliance weren't the terms of partners.
Castellano chastised the Westies for murdering two important mafia loan sharks and told Coonan his crew should pay the family 10 % of all its illegal proceeds with the Gambinos financing the loan sharking in return. Coonan had set out as a young man to run his own outfit free of anybody's thumb and what he'd built instead was a tribute operation for the Italians downtown. He traded Spillane's boot for Castellano's and he wore it. because the alternative was the kind of conversation nobody in that business survives.
It cost him men along the way that the law never touched him for. In January of 1978, Coonan, with Featherstone and another enforcer named Anton Lusich, shot and dismembered a loan -sharking associate named Richard Tassiello after finding out he'd been skimming. That was how Coonan ran things. No slow bleed, no warning shot off a rooftop this time. Straight to the finish. In 1979, the government tried him for an earlier killing. The murder of a man named Harold Whitehead and a jury let him go. He was convicted on weapons charges instead and sentenced to four years in federal prison.
He did his time and came home and picked the organization up again like a man picking up a tool he'd set down. After his release, he resumed power but was arrested for murder again in 1986. The 1986 arrest wasn't the end by itself. The end started somewhere colder than a courtroom, in Coonan's own head, in a decision to get rid of a problem the way he'd always gotten rid of problems. Mickey Featherstone had been loyal a long time, but loyal men asked questions eventually, and by the middle of the 80s, Featherstone had worked out that Coonan, sitting pretty out in New Jersey by then, had sold Hell's Kitchen to the Italians and kept the proceeds for himself while the old crew took the risks.
Featherstone talked about it. Kuhnen heard about the talking, and Kuhnen decided a man with doubts was a man better put away. In April of 1985, a Westie named Michael Holley was murdered. The job had Billy Bokin's hand in it, but the frame that got built pointed at Featherstone. And in March of 1986, a jury convicted him and a judge gave him 25 years. Featherstone sat with that sentence and understood exactly what had been done to him and by whom. His wife Sissy wasn't the type to sit still for it.
She started wearing a wire and she got Boken talking on tape about the Holly killing and about wearing a disguise to pull it off. And with that evidence in hand showing Featherstone's own gang had turned on him and set him up, his conviction was overturned in September 1986 and Featherstone agreed to become an informant. What came out of Featherstone after that broke the Westies clean in half. With the new information Featherstone provided in 1986, Prosecutors obtained indictments against eight members of the Westies, including leader Jimmy Coonan, and all but one were convicted, marking the demise of the Westies' reign.
On September 17th, 1987, the United States Attorney and the Manhattan District Attorney handed up an indictment against Coonan and nine others, Coonan's own wife Edna among them, under the federal racketeering statute. And the charges ran the length of everything the Westies had done for 20 years, extortion, loansharking, gambling, narcotics, kidnapping, eight murders. The trial that followed ran into 1988, and it wasn't a quiet one. Featherstone took the stand and told it all. The killings, the dismemberments, the loansharking ledgers.
And beside him, a second -turned Westie named William Beatty backed up the same story in the same courtroom. And Coonan's own niece gave testimony that lined up with both of them. A man doesn't survive that kind of corroboration. The jury convicted Coonan of 10 charges and acquitted him on one. In May of 1988, taking into account mandatory consecutive terms, the district court imposed a total sentence of 75 years, along with a million -dollar fine, and the judge went on record recommending Coonan never see parole at all.
Eight of his co -defendants went down with him. Featherstone didn't do a day for any of it that mattered. He pleaded guilty himself to a single racticuring count and a judge gave him probation for his trouble. And by December of 1988, he was out and gone into a new name somewhere the Westies couldn't reach him, which by then wasn't very far at all because there wasn't much of the Westies left to do any reaching. Coonan went to a federal institution and he's been there since. An old man now, in a cell in Pennsylvania, still filing the appeals a man files when 75 years is the number on the paper and he was never going to outlive it fairly.
The boy who climbed a tenement roof to empty a magazine at Mickey Spillane got everything he set out to get. The whole West Side, the whole operation, every dollar Spillane used to collect. He just never got to keep it clean the way he meant to. And in the end, a kid with a choir boy face and a wire -wearing wife took it all back off him in a federal courtroom, the same way Coonan had always taken things, which is to say, without mercy and without much warning. That's the part of the story that has the shape of justice in it, if you're inclined to look at it that way.
Most men in that business aren't inclined. They just note the facts and move along the avenue. the way Hell's Kitchen always has, with its dead men and its alive ones walking past each other like nothing happened at all. As always, stay curious, my friends!
Podbean