MICKEY SPILLANE: The Gentleman Gangster Murdered by the Westies
The Story
Hell's Kitchen never smelled like roses. It smelled like river fog and diesel and the inside of a fist. And for 17 years, one man owned it.
Michael J. Spillane. Born July 13, 1933, Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan. Irish parents Michael Anthony Spillane and Margaret Curran. Sacred Heart School — skipped two grades, scholarship at 12 to Rice High School. Leaves after two years to support widowed mother.
#MickeySpillane #HellsKitchen #Westies #JimmyCoonan #RoyDeMeo #TrueCrime #Mafia #IrishMob #OrganizedCrime #NewYorkCity #GentlemanGangster #MobHistory #JavitsCenter #MickeyFeatherstone
Hell's Kitchen never smelled like roses, not even on the mornings when Mickey Spillane sent flowers to a sick neighbor and meant it. It smelled like river fog and diesel and the inside of a fist. And that was the only honest thing about the whole West Side in those years. Honest, the way a knife is honest when you finally see the blade. He was born there. Michael J. Spillane on July 13th, 1933. in Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan, a twin born into a neighborhood that raised its sons on tenement stairwells and taught them early that the law was something that happened to other people, somewhere else, to men who could afford it.
He was born to Irish parents, Michael Anthony Spillane and Margaret Curran, and he was smart in the way the nuns noticed. The kind of smart that gets a boy skipped two grades and handed a scholarship he doesn't get to keep. He excelled academically and was skipped two grades at Sacred Heart School, and at 12 was awarded a full scholarship to Rice High School. But the West Side collects its debts early, and Spillane left Rice after two years to help support his widowed mother. That was the first door that closed on him.
He went looking for another one and found it with a gun in his hand. At 17, he was shot in the back running away after holding up the Roxy Theatre in October, 1952. The fleeing fell in law still on the books then, still the kind of thing a cop could do to a boy and call it justice. He did his stretch, four years in prison, and came out the way men like that always come out, older in the wrong direction. with no door left open to him but the one marked crime. So he took it. After his release, Spillane started as a numbers runner for organized crime figures in Hell's Kitchen, learning the trade from the bottom, the way a man learns a trade when the trade is the only church that will have him.
His teacher was a boss named Hughie Mulligan, who for years had headed the criminal activities of the Irish mob in Hell's Kitchen during the 1950s. And when Mulligan's time ran out, in 1960, Mickey took over the rackets left to him by his predecessor. He inherited bookmaking and numbers and the usual companion to both. The money lent at rates that turned a man's hope into a leash. He married well, or at least married smart, taking Maureen McManus, the daughter of the Democratic district leader, Eugene McManus, which is the kind of marriage a man makes when he understands that in that city, Politics and crime were just two doors into the same room.
He ran it like a man who had read the part of the gangster story where the gangster gets to be loved. He sent flowers to neighbors in the hospital and provided turkeys to needy families during Thanksgiving. And he wouldn't allow drug dealing on his turf and would visit sick residents, a code of his own invention applied selectively the way all such codes are. They called him what the street always calls a man who is careful about his cruelty. He was the so -called gentleman gangster, a marked contrast to the violent Westies mob members who succeeded him.
And that contrast would turn out to be the whole of his epitaph written years before he was in the ground to read it. Every kingdom has its heir apparent, sharpening something in the dark. and Spillane's was a kid from the neighborhood who hadn't done anything yet, except hate him, cleanly, for a reason that was entirely Spillane's own making. When Coonan was a young man, his father John was kidnapped, pistol -whipped, and severely beaten by Mickey Spillane, who ran the kidnap for ransom trade against local merchants the way other men ran a dry cleaner's, a service with a price list.
It didn't occur to him, probably, that the boy watching his father get beaten would grow up remembering every second of it. Author T .J. English has credited this event as Coonan's motivating factor for everything that came after. And when you looked at what came after, that made a certain terrible sense. Revenge, in that part of town, wasn't a flaw in a man's character. It was the only inheritance anybody handed down clean. The kid came for him early and came for him loud. In 1966, Kuhnen fired a machine gun at Spillane and his associates from atop a Hell's Kitchen tenement building, 18 years old, and already passed caring whether he lived through the attempt.
He emptied a whole 30 -round magazine in one long burst at Spillane and the men with him, and for all that noise, For all that lead sent down into the street like judgment, Coonan wounded no one, but Spillen understood that the younger hoodlum was not to be taken lightly. Spillen answered the only way the neighborhood recognized as an answer. He went to the father, not the son, and slapped him around and told him to get his son under control, which was a mistake dressed up as a solution. The kind men make when they still believe the old rules will hold the new world in place.
They never do. The old rules are just the new world's first casualty. Coonan went to prison for a while on the back half of that decade, picked up on kidnapping and murder charges that were pleaded down to Class C manslaughter, and a man might have hoped that was the end of it. The way a man hopes rain will put out a fire he can't see anymore. It wasn't. He was released in late 1971 and continued his war with the West Side Gang, and this time he came back patient, which is always worse than coming back loud.
By then, the city itself had found a reason to want Spillane gone, and the city's reasons were always bigger and colder than any one man's grudge. There was a convention center going up, the kind of construction that moves a great deal of concrete and a great deal of money in the same gesture, and it sat square inside Hell's Kitchen, square inside what Spillane still called his. The Genovese crime family sought control over the soon -to -be -built Jacob K. Javits Convention Center, and a power struggle emerged between Spillane and James Coonan, a younger upstart.
Since the Convention Center was located in Spillane's neighborhood, He refused to allow any involvement by the Italians. For a while, against the kind of odds that should have ended it instantly, he held them off. Although the Italian gangsters greatly outnumbered the members of the Irish mob, Spillane was successful in keeping control of the Convention Centre and Hell's Kitchen. A man doesn't embarrass the Genovese family and walk away clean. The Italians, frustrated and embarrassed by their defeat, responded by hiring a rogue Irish -American hitman named Joseph Mad Dog Sullivan to assassinate Tom Devaney, Eddie the Butcher Comiskey, and Tom the Greek Capetos, three of Spillane's top lieutenants.
Comiskey went down first and worst, a man who'd stayed on decent terms with both sides of the coming war and got no credit for the diplomacy. He was shot at point -blank range and killed by Joseph Mad Dog Sullivan while drinking at the Sunbright Bar on August 20, 1976. And his death was only one entry on a ledger the Genovese family kept with patient bureaucratic cruelty, one of many ordered by Salerno seeking to eliminate high -ranking and veteran members of Spillane's organization. Every man that fell was a brick.
pulled out from under the gentleman gangster's house, and nobody was putting any bricks back. It was no longer safe to be Mickey Spillane in Hell's Kitchen, and Spillane, who had never been a fool even when he was being sentimental, knew it. Hell's Kitchen was no longer safe for Spillane and his family, and he moved to the then Irish working -class neighborhood of Woodside, Queens. It was the kind of retreat a smart man makes and calls strategy. and it bought him nothing but a different address to die at.
With Spillane gone, his control of the rackets in Hell's Kitchen began to deteriorate, and Coonan became the neighborhood's boss, although some still viewed Spillane as boss. On paper, in the rooms where such things were still decided, with something resembling formality, Spillane was still viewed by the Commission as the Irish mob boss on the West Side. A title that was starting to mean exactly as much as a king's crown means to a king already in exile. Coonan, for his part, had grown up and grown smarter.
And smarter in that world meant finding Italian friends instead of Italian enemies. He had around him now a new breed of help, younger and hungrier. Chief among them, a Vietnam veteran named Mickey Featherstone, whose penchant for violence and intimidation caught the eye of Coonan. And Featherstone became Coonan's right -hand man by 1976. And Coonan had found, or made, a use for a lone shark named Ruby Stein, a man who worked the same streets as the Genovese people and who ended up, in the end, less a business partner than a bridge.
Coonan killed him and killed him with a showman's cruelty, beheaded in 1977 in a move to erase Coonan's debt and proved the Westies' power through viciousness, according to testimony an informant gave years afterward. It was a bridge paid for in blood, but it got him a cross. Dimeo initially came into contact with Coonan after the latter murdered and dismembered loan shark, Ruby Stein. And that contact was the last door Mickey Spillane would ever need to worry about, because on the other side of it stood a Gambino crew captain named Roy DeMeo, a man who killed for a living the way other men punch a clock.
When Coonan was released from prison, he sought to align himself with the Gambino crime family through an up -and -coming mobster from Brooklyn named Roy DeMeo. The arrangement they came to was as plain and as filthy as any deal ever struck in that city. Coonan recruited the infamous DeMeo after the pair struck a deal. By eliminating Spillane, DeMeo's crew could then do business with his successor. It was business the way a knife in an alley is business, dressed up afterward in the language of commerce, because the language of commerce is easier to live with than the truth.
Which is that men were trading a man's life for a shot at his rackets. On May 13, 1977, it came due. Mickey Spillane, 43 years old, semi -retired by then, or trying to be, was out walking his own small stretch of borrowed peace. While walking down 59th Street and Woodside, a middle -class neighborhood in Queens, Spillane was shot and killed by an unknown gunman after approaching an unmarked car. He had been shot before, as a kid, running from a theater holdup with nothing in his pocket but bad luck.
This time, there was no running. He was shot five times outside his apartment in Woodside, Queens, and the city that had tolerated him as a kind of local color, a bookmaker who gave out turkeys, a killer who visited the sick, closed over the spot where he fell the way water closes over a stone. It has long been rumored that the DeMeo crew murdered Spillane as a favor to Coonan, with Roy DeMeo being the shooter. Nobody was ever convicted for pulling that trigger. Mickey Featherstone was arrested on suspicion of the killing and was acquitted, and the file on who actually fired those five shots closed the way most of that city's old debts closed, unpaid in any courtroom, settled instead in the only currency the neighborhood ever really trusted.
There's a kind of silence that falls over a street after a killing like that, not grief exactly, more like a held breath. the whole block waiting to see whose name gets said next. Coonan didn't wait long to make sure everybody understood whose name that was. Coonan took over as boss of the Hell's Kitchen Irish Mob and the Spillane who had once walked into the father's house and settled a score with a slap found too late that there is no slap hard enough to undo an 18 -year -old's hatred once you've let it live for a decade.
The feud that had started with a kidnapping and a beating ended with a body on a queen's sidewalk and a gang that bore the dead man's enemy's name running everything the dead man had built. What came after was its own kind of epilogue and not a gentle one. Although Spillane was in semi -retirement, his death marked the official end of the decade -long gang war between him and Coonan, as power over Hell's Kitchen fell to the Westies. Coonan ran it for a decade more, and ran it the way the neighborhood had long since learned to expect, with the quiet handshake that had killed Spillane now hardening into something permanent.
The alliance with the Gambinos marked the beginning of the end for the Irish mob, as after Spillane's death, Coonan eventually worked for the Gambinos, which is its own kind of poetic justice, if you've got the stomach to call it justice at all. A man who murdered his way to independence ending up In the final accounting, just another hired hand for the Italians he'd once needed to borrow a killer from. That's the whole sad arithmetic of the West Side in those years. A gentleman gangster who gave out turkeys and ran a kidnapping racket in the same week.
A boy who watched his father get pistol -whipped and grew up to trade a corpse for a business partnership. A city too busy with its conventions and its concrete. to notice that the men killing each other over a few square blocks of Hell's Kitchen were, in the end, only proving the same point over and over. That there is no code in that life worth the name, only timing, and the question of who gets to the gun first. Mickey Spillane got to it first for seventeen years. On a quiet street in Woodside, his time simply ran out.
The way it runs out for every man in that business who ever mistook a reputation for armor. As always, stay curious, my friends.
Podbean