The Woman Who Wouldn't Take The Wrong Son: Christine Collins
The Story
Lincoln Heights, March 10, 1928. 5PM. A telephone operator gives her 9-year-old son a dime for the movies on Pasadena Avenue. Lumber jacket, gray cap. He doesn't come back.
A massive manhunt. Silver Lake dredged. National wires. Nothing.
Then August 1928, DeKalb, Illinois. A 12-year-old runaway named Arthur Hutchins Jr. says he's Walter Collins. Illinois cops don't buy it. LAPD Captain J.J. Jones does — he needs a win.
Christine knows in a minute he's not her boy. Jones tells her to "try the boy out." She keeps a stranger's son for three weeks.
She returns with dental records, teacher affidavits, neighbor statements. Jones doesn't apologize. He has her committed.
Code 12. The LAPD's back-pocket term to jail anyone "difficult or inconvenient." No judge. No hearing. Psychopathic ward, Los Angeles County General Hospital. 10 days behind a locked door for telling the truth.
While she's inside, Arthur confesses. He's not Walter. Only then they let her out.
She sues and wins $10,800. J.J. Jones never pays. Not in 1928, not in 1941 when she tries again.
The trail ends in Wineville — now Mira Loma — at Gordon Stewart Northcott's chicken ranch. With his mother Sarah Louise and nephew Sanford Clark. Northcott hanged at San Quentin Oct 2, 1930, age 23. Never tried for Walter. No body ever found with Walter's name on it that his mother could bury.
Christine Collins died December 1964, 75, still hoping. She outlived Jones, Hutchins, and Northcott.
Told in Philip Marlowe noir style. This is the true story behind Clint Eastwood's Changeling — with the part Hollywood left out: Walter's father, Walter Anson, writing from Folsom Prison.
Fireside Chat with Cage.
Stay curious, my friends.
Lincoln Heights, a Saturday evening in March, the kind of soft gold light that makes a city look innocent of everything it's about to do to you. A woman named Christine Collins gave her boy a dime for the picture show and watched him walk off toward Pasadena Avenue. His mother, Christine Collins, a telephone operator, had given him a dime to go to the movies at a nearby theater. Nine years old, in a lumber jacket and a gray cap, walking into the kind of evening nobody thinks to remember until it's the last one.
He didn't come back. Not that night. Not the next. Not ever in any way that let a mother stop waiting. I didn't take this one. Nobody could have paid me enough to sit across from Christine Collins and tell her what I eventually came to believe. But I followed it the way you follow a case that isn't yours because some stories get into your coat pocket and won't shake loose. The father's name belongs in this before anything else, since everybody forgets him, including at the time the cops who were supposed to be looking.
Walter Joseph Collins, who'd been born Walter Joseph Anson and picked up an alias the way some men pick up a drink, was doing a stretch in Folsom for robbery when his son vanished. His father, Walter Collins Sr., was serving time in Folsom State Prison for robbery. He wasn't a ghost in the case, either. He worked the prison cafeteria, and part of his job was reporting other inmates for infractions, which is a fine way to make a man a lot of enemies in a place with nothing but time to carry a grudge.
Collins's father thought former prison inmates were responsible for his son's disappearance in an attempt to get revenge. since he worked at the prison's cafeteria and was responsible for reporting other inmates infractions. A letter came out of Folsom in those first weeks, the old man's own theory of the crime, written from behind a wall he couldn't do a thing about. It's a sorry picture, a father who can't leave his cell to look for his boy, writing home his best guess at who might have taken him.
and nobody with the time or the inclination to chase it down properly. The marriage itself had been over by then in every way that mattered. Christine was keeping house and raising Walter alone on a telephone operator's wage, her husband's criminal record, the family's only inheritance. So that's the father. A convict, a swindler who'd worn the Collins name like a cheap suit, and for whatever it's worth, A man who loved the boy enough to name his own enemies from a prison cell. He never once got blamed properly, and he never got to do anything about any of it.
That's the kind of justice this story deals in. The mother did everything right, and it didn't matter. She called it in, the papers ran it, and the department put on a show of looking. The police conducted a massive manhunt for Walter. They dredged a local lake, collected tips, and launched a national campaign to find the missing boy. Nothing came of any of it, and the LAPD, already wearing the public's contempt for a string of other scandals, needed a win bad enough to manufacture one. In August, out in DeKalb, Illinois, a drifting kid with a hard luck story got picked up by local cops, and somewhere between Illinois and Los Angeles, he became Walter Collins.
He wasn't. He was Arthur Hutchins, a runaway who'd lost his mother and couldn't stand his stepmother, hitchhiking the country and taking whatever identity kept him fed. After Arthur's mother died, the boy ran away from his father and stepmother. He was hitchhiking around the U .S. when in a DeKalb, Illinois cafe, someone told him he resembled a missing boy from Los Angeles. The department needed the Collins case closed more than it needed it closed correctly. So a boy who didn't match got put on a train west anyway.
When he was picked up, juvenile authorities were skeptical about his story. But police were so desperate to close the Collins case that they insisted on its veracity. Christine knew inside of a minute. A mother always does. But Captain J .J. Jones, the man running the case, had his own reputation riding on a tidy resolution, and he wasn't a man built for being told he was wrong by a telephone operator in a worn coat. He talked her into taking the boy home anyway, told her the months of grief had scrambled her memory, that the boy only looked different because he'd been through hell.
Under pressure to resolve the case, the officer in charge, Captain J .J. Jones, convinced her to try the boy out. by taking him home. She did it the way a drowning woman grabs whatever's floating by. Three weeks, she kept a stranger's son in her house, feeding him, watching him sleep in Walter's bed. And at the end of it, she knew exactly what she'd known at the station platform. She returned three weeks later, again saying that he was not her son. This time she came armed. Dental records. signed statements from neighbors and teachers who'd known the real boy.
She brought with her Walter's dental records and signed statements from people who knew Walter saying that this boy was not him. It should have ended the matter. Instead, it ended something else. Jones had heard enough. A woman contradicting him, embarrassing a department that had already staked its battered credibility, on this one small, manufactured miracle wasn't a problem to be solved with facts. It was a problem to be solved with power, and Jones had exactly the kind he needed. Although she had dental records and backing from friends to prove her case, Jones accused her of being a bad mother and bringing ridicule to the police.
What happened next is the part of this case I can't get out of my head, and it's the part that matters most, because it's the part where the machinery of the law stopped pretending to serve the people underneath it. Jones had her committed, not questioned, not warned, committed to the psychopathic ward of the Los Angeles County General Hospital under something the department carried in its back pocket for exactly this kind of inconvenience, a Code 12. Jones had Christine committed to the psychiatric ward at Los Angeles County Hospital under a Code 12 internment.
A term used to jail or commit someone who was deemed difficult or an inconvenience. No judge, no hearing, no diagnosis worth the name. Just a captain's signature and a door that locked behind her. Think about what that means for a woman whose only crime was refusing to stop telling the truth. She walked in, sane, grieving, and, righteously, furious. And the state's answer was to make her certifiable by decree, to file her under the same heading as the city's drunks and vagrants, and anyone else inconvenient enough to need putting away quietly.
Captain J .J. Jones, the officer in charge of the case, accused her of being a bad mother and had her committed to a psychiatric ward. at Los Angeles County Hospital under Code 12, a term the police could use to institutionalize someone for being difficult or inconvenient. She sat behind that door, not knowing if her son was alive, not knowing if she'd ever get out, surrounded by the genuinely ill while outside her case, kept right on being handled by the man who'd put her there. Ten days. That's how long it took.
While she was locked up, Jones kept at the boy and the kid finally folded, admitted he wasn't Walter Collins at all, that he was Arthur Hutchins, 12 years old, and he'd never been anybody's missing son. Jones questioned the boy, who admitted to being 12 -year -old Arthur Hutchins Jr., a runaway from Iowa. Only then did they let her out. Collins was released ten days after Hutchins admitted that he was not her son and filed a lawsuit against the Los Angeles Police Department. She sued and eventually she won a judgment of $10 ,800 against Jones personally.
He never paid a dime of it, not then, not after a second try in court over a decade later. She won a lawsuit against Jones and was awarded $10 ,800, which Jones refused to pay. Christine attempted several times to collect the money owed her by Jones, including a 1941 court case in which she attempted to collect a judgment in the Superior Court. That's how it usually goes when the House loses a hand it never should have dealt. It writes the debt off and keeps the chips. The real end of this one, if a case like this can be said to end, came out of a chicken ranch in a nowhere stretch of Riverside County called Wineville.
A man named Gordon Stuart Northcott had been running a horror out there, luring and murdering boys with help from his own mother and a terrified nephew he kept as a kind of slave. When it finally came apart and the nephew talked, The testimony and what little evidence the ground gave up pointed straight at a nine -year -old from Lincoln Heights. Investigators in California later concluded that Walter had been murdered by Gordon Stewart Northcott as part of the Wineville Chicken Coop murders. The state never even bothered trying Northcott for it specifically, charging him instead with three other killings it could prove just as cleanly.
The state chose not to prosecute Gordon for Walter's murder, and instead brought him to trial for the murders of three other young boys, for which there was also forensic evidence. Northcott went to the gallows at San Quentin in 1930, and officially, as far as the record stands, that's where the Collins case closes its books. I'll give it to you straight, the way I'd give it to a client who was paying me not to varnish it. No body was ever brought back with Walter Collins' name on it that his mother could bury.
What came out of that ground was fragments, clothing, and a drifting nephew's word, and a state eager to call its ledgers balanced. Christine Collins was never, by her own account, fully convinced, and some who knew her said she went on hoping for the rest of her life that somewhere her boy had simply walked out of all of it alive. the way one of Northcott's other presumed victims eventually did, years later, very much breathing. Five years after Gordon Northcott's execution, one of the boys previously thought to be murdered by Northcott was found alive and well.
As Walter Collins' body had not been found, Christine Collins still hoped that Walter had survived. She never stopped looking. She lived quiet after that, under other names sometimes. away from the reporters who'd once made her humiliation a public circus. She used aliases to stay out of the media and lived alone through the 1950s. She died in this city in December of 1964, 75 years old, having outlived the captain who locked her away, the imposter who wore her son's name for three weeks, and the killer the state said had taken him.
What I keep coming back to isn't the chicken coop. or the dental records or even the hanging at San Quentin. It's a woman walking into a hospital ward sane and walking out ten days later having been taught by a badge and a signature exactly how little the truth is worth against a man who doesn't want to hear it. That's not a mystery that gets solved. That's just the weather in this town. And it was raining on Christine Collins long after everybody else had gone in out of it. As always, stay curious, my friends.
Podbean