All Episodes
S1E75
The Woman Who Wouldn't Take The Wrong Son: Christine Collins
•13:15

The Woman Who Wouldn't Take The Wrong Son: Christine Collins

0:00 / 13:15

The Story

Lincoln Heights, March 10, 1928. 5PM. A telephone operator gives her 9-year-old son a dime for the movies on Pasadena Avenue. Lumber jacket, gray cap. He doesn't come back.

A massive manhunt. Silver Lake dredged. National wires. Nothing.

Then August 1928, DeKalb, Illinois. A 12-year-old runaway named Arthur Hutchins Jr. says he's Walter Collins. Illinois cops don't buy it. LAPD Captain J.J. Jones does — he needs a win.

Christine knows in a minute he's not her boy. Jones tells her to "try the boy out." She keeps a stranger's son for three weeks.

She returns with dental records, teacher affidavits, neighbor statements. Jones doesn't apologize. He has her committed.

Code 12. The LAPD's back-pocket term to jail anyone "difficult or inconvenient." No judge. No hearing. Psychopathic ward, Los Angeles County General Hospital. 10 days behind a locked door for telling the truth.

While she's inside, Arthur confesses. He's not Walter. Only then they let her out.

She sues and wins $10,800. J.J. Jones never pays. Not in 1928, not in 1941 when she tries again.

The trail ends in Wineville — now Mira Loma — at Gordon Stewart Northcott's chicken ranch. With his mother Sarah Louise and nephew Sanford Clark. Northcott hanged at San Quentin Oct 2, 1930, age 23. Never tried for Walter. No body ever found with Walter's name on it that his mother could bury.

Christine Collins died December 1964, 75, still hoping. She outlived Jones, Hutchins, and Northcott.

Told in Philip Marlowe noir style. This is the true story behind Clint Eastwood's Changeling — with the part Hollywood left out: Walter's father, Walter Anson, writing from Folsom Prison.

Fireside Chat with Cage.

Stay curious, my friends.